• NAU shooting defendant Steven Jones describes the shooting

    NAU shooting defendant Steven Jones describes the shooting

  • NAU shooting victim describes moment he was shot

    NAU shooting victim describes moment he was shot

  • Steven Jones' NAU murder trial begins

    Steven Jones’ NAU murder trial begins

  • Steven Jones' trial in NAU shooting: Prosecution's opening statement

    Steven Jones’ trial in NAU shooting: Prosecution’s opening statement

  • Steven Jones' trial in NAU shooting: Defense's opening statement

    Steven Jones’ trial in NAU shooting: Defense’s opening statement

  • Judge rules on evidence in NAU shooting case

    Judge rules on evidence in NAU shooting case

  • Steven Jones weeps as he is granted conditional release until trial

    Steven Jones weeps as he is granted conditional release until trial

  • NAU Shooting Suspect In Court

    NAU Shooting Suspect In Court

  • Body camera video from scene of NAU shooting

    Body camera video from scene of NAU shooting

  • A haunting 911 call received the night of the NAU shooting

    A haunting 911 call received the night of the NAU shooting

  • A 911 call received the night of the NAU shooting

    A 911 call received the night of the NAU shooting

  • 911 calls into NAU Police after shootings

    911 calls into NAU Police after shootings

  • Victim's father: "We got to stop this throughout the country"

    Victim’s father: “We got to stop this throughout the country”

  • Candlelight for Colin Brough

    Candlelight for Colin Brough

  • Prayer vigil for NAU shooting victims

    Prayer vigil for NAU shooting victims

  • Close to home: Students react to NAU shooting

    Close to home: Students react to NAU shooting

  • Witness Dion Harris at Flagstaff Shooting

    Witness Dion Harris at Flagstaff Shooting

  • Reporter Dennis Wagner at the scene of the NAU shooting

    Reporter Dennis Wagner at the scene of the NAU shooting

  • NAU freshman held in shooting that left 1 student dead, 3 wounded

    NAU freshman held in shooting that left 1 student dead, 3 wounded

  • Fatal shooting reported at Northern Arizona University

    Fatal shooting reported at Northern Arizona University

  • Why more school shootings happen in the US than anywhere else

    Why more school shootings happen in the US than anywhere else

Coconino County Superior Court Judge Dan Slayton plans to hold a hearing at 9 a.m. Thursday to discuss the request for mistrial.

FLAGSTAFF — The judge in the Northern Arizona University shooting trial suspended jury deliberations for the day Wednesday amid concerns that jurors were not given complete information about when defendant Steven Jones first asserted that he acted in self-defense after shooting four students in October 2015.

Jones’ defense attorneys have asked for a mistrial as a result.

Coconino County Superior Court Judge Dan Slayton will hold a hearing at 9 a.m. Thursday at which prosecutors and defense attorneys can argue for or against a mistrial or suggest other remedies — for example, permitting further closing arguments or allowing the jury to hear additional information.

NAU shooting

“The jury cannot be left with the impression that the only self-defense arguments (that Jones made) were made at the police station,” Slayton told the attorneys during a hastily called meeting Wednesday morning. Jurors were seen filing out of the courthouse shortly after the judge concluded the meeting with attorneys.

Jones made similar self-defense statements in the back of the police car minutes after he was arrested, but prosecutors successfully argued before the trial started to keep that information from jurors.

An officer’s dashboard camera recorded Jones saying, “Why did they punch me?” and “Why did they chase me?” Jones also told a student who asked him to put down the gun that he acted in “self-defense.”

During pretrial arguments, the prosecution characterized Jones’ statements to police first-responders as fabricated excuses. And the prosecution claimed they are “hearsay” — that is, secondhand accounts, which are not allowed in court.

Deputy County Attorney Ammon Barker told the judge on Wednesday that the statements he presented from Jones during closing arguments a day earlier were presented in context and “it wasn’t an intentional misrepresentation of the facts.”

Defense attorneys, however, accused prosecutors of  “gross and intentional prosecutorial misconduct” for leaving the jury with the impression that Jones did not raise self-defense claims until well after the shootings.

Jones, 20, is charged with first-degree murder in the death of NAU student Colin Brough, and aggravated assault for wounding three other students — Nick Piring, Nick Prato and Kyle Zientek — during a fight that spilled onto campus in the early hours of Oct. 9, 2015.

Jones was punched, ran to his car, removed a gun from the glove box, then walked toward a gathered crowd. He testified that he shot Brough and wounded Piring as they came at him again. Prato and Zientek were shot in a second barrage of bullets moments later.

Jones claimed that he was jumped by others as he tried to administer aid to Brough, and began firing blindly. Prato testified that Jones was looking at him when he fired, and Zientek said he was shot as he tried to run away.

Attorneys made their closing arguments in the case Tuesday after three weeks of testimony. The jury began deliberations Tuesday afternoon.

Prosecutors maintain Jones acted with premeditation. The defense contends he acted in self-defense.

READ MORE:

Opening arguments: Was Jones an ‘assassin’ or defending himself?

 ‘Most intense pain you’ve ever felt,’ gunshot victim testifies

Jones takes stand, says he feared for his life

Closing arguments: Jurors to sort through different versions of story

Autoplay

Show Thumbnails

Show Captions

Read or Share this story: http://azc.cc/2pmtSuF